You guys have bad memories! I found a lot of games that might could fit on this list.
However, to remain impartial I am NOT officially nominating these. Just throwing them out there for you guys to consider. Someone else will have to actually care enough to nominate.
All of these were movies that were 1) rejected 2) didn't break any site rules, and 3) got a ok viewer response (majority of yes votes)
Jewel master -
http://tasvideos.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5868 - I honestly think this one would have been accepted had it been submitted today
Rocman X -
http://tasvideos.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7597
Little Nemo -
http://tasvideos.org/2010S.html Rejected due to known improvements, I think things are more lax about that now
Firemen -
http://tasvideos.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5588&highlight= I think this one might be publishable these days
Sandra no Daibouken -
http://tasvideos.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5522&highlight= - maybe I was too harsh on this one, seems publishable entertainmentwise
Marvel Land -
http://tasvideos.org/1948S.html - borderline & got decent votes
Bram Stokers Dracula -
http://tasvideos.org/1881S.html - decent votes & borderline possibly publishable
Gruevy! -
http://tasvideos.org/1684S.html
Gyromite -
http://tasvideos.org/1668S.html - classic game (nostalgia factor) decent votes
Super C 1 player -
http://tasvideos.org/1660S.html - one of the most optimized runs I ever rejected, A+ on tech quality, but was a questionable category
Animaniacs -
http://tasvideos.org/1606S.html - got a majority of yes votes, possibly passable
Claymates -
http://tasvideos.org/742S.html - maybe it is better suited these days?
Robin Hood -
http://tasvideos.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5396 - I think this one was canceled so it wouldn't get rejected, otherwise I wouldnt' add a canceled to the list
Cybernator -
http://tasvideos.org/519S.html - going old school now!
And what the hell, how about a movie that improves a published movie by 80 minutes:
http://tasvideos.org/2012S.html