Lego Island 2: The Brickster's Revenge is the sequel to the PC game Lego Island and features varied gameplay such as platforming, adventure, and side-scrolling shooter sections. Our protagonist Pepper has unwittingly let the Brickster escape from his prison by letting him eat enough hot peppers to breathe fire and melt down his prison cell. The Brickster then steals the Constructopedia, the instructions to constructing all the buildings on Lego Island, and scatters them across various other islands and worlds. It's up to Pepper now to get these pages back and catch the Brickster so that he'll pay for his crimes.

Cephla completes the game as fast as possible by exploiting a game restart glitch that allows them to go out of bounds and skip to the final world of the game.