I think you should keep this here and let people vote on it. I'm not a judge but it seems that the reception for this movie is good so I hope it will be published.
When you'll submit the new version, people will vote on that too. If it's good, then a judge or an admin will decide if there can be two branches alongside (this one + the pacifist) or, if the other run is more entertaining, it can obsolete this one.
Just my opinion.
I think I found a possible improvement:
In the tower, could you somehow manipulate the last prisoner to be in the first cell possible? I never played this version, so I don't know if the location is fixed. It's random on the GBC though, so this would mean a bit of RNG-Fun (which I absolutely can't do)
Current project: Gex 3 any%
Paused: Gex 64 any%
There are no N64 emulators. Just SM64 emulators with hacky support for all the other games.
Joined: 8/26/2006
Posts: 1139
Location: United Kingdom
Noob Irdoh wrote:
I think you should keep this here and let people vote on it. I'm not a judge but it seems that the reception for this movie is good so I hope it will be published.
I disagree. The votes and the comments tell different stories here. While the votes are somewhat positive, this run has received poorer feedback in the thread than one would desire for a published run. The feedback suggests that many, if not most, viewers found this game too boring. Therefore, TimmyAkmed, if you honestly believe that you can improve the entertainment value of this run it would be wise to do so and cancel this submission (though it should be noted that I am not familiar with this game and so I cannot comment on whether a pacifist goal would be more entertaining (or entertaining enough, for that matter)). Also, you mentioned that you have "found some tricks." If these happen to be time saving tricks then, yes, you should definitely cancel and submit a new run.
I think I found a possible improvement:
In the tower, could you somehow manipulate the last prisoner to be in the first cell possible? I never played this version, so I don't know if the location is fixed. It's random on the GBC though, so this would mean a bit of RNG-Fun (which I absolutely can't do)
The positions of the prisoners is fixed so it's impossible to manipulate the luck here.
I disagree. The votes and the comments tell different stories here. While the votes are somewhat positive, this run has received poorer feedback in the thread than one would desire for a published run. The feedback suggests that many, if not most, viewers found this game too boring. Therefore, TimmyAkmed, if you honestly believe that you can improve the entertainment value of this run it would be wise to do so and cancel this submission (though it should be noted that I am not familiar with this game and so I cannot comment on whether a pacifist goal would be more entertaining (or entertaining enough, for that matter)). Also, you mentioned that you have "found some tricks." If these happen to be time saving tricks then, yes, you should definitely cancel and submit a new run.
I think my new race is more entertaining than the first (It is subjective) but this game is pretty hard to make it interesting. I found a way to win probably more than 10 seconds in all the race. So I think i will finish and see if it's more interesting to watch.
So I'm not sure it will be more entertaining for you, should I cancel it in this case?
